If you’re serious about starting or scaling a newsletter in 2026, chances are you’ve come across two powerful platforms: Beehiiv and Substack. Both are designed to empower creators to grow audiences, monetize content, and simplify email publishing. But which one actually gives you more control, scalability, and value for your efforts?
In this post, we’ll explore how Beehiiv and Substack compare, from features to user experience, monetization options, and long-term growth potential so you can make the best decision for your newsletter journey.
Disclosure: This post may contain affiliate links. If you click and make a purchase, I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. See Full Disclosure.
What is Beehiiv?
Beehiiv, launched by a team of former Morning Brew employees, is an email platform built specifically for growth-minded newsletter creators. While it’s just as easy to use as Substack, Beehiiv goes beyond content delivery, offering creators full control, detailed analytics, and tools to scale.
What is Substack?
Substack is a well-known newsletter platform that made waves for making paid newsletters accessible to everyone. Its appeal lies in its simplicity. You sign up, start writing, and Substack takes care of the rest, emails, subscriptions, and even payments.
What Makes Beehiiv and Substack Stand Out
Before diving into features, let’s understand what these platforms were designed for.
- Substack is built for ease, simplicity, and the writing experience. Think of it as Medium + Email + Monetization.
- Beehiiv, created by early Morning Brew team members, is designed for growth, segmentation, and newsletter business infrastructure.
If you're starting your first newsletter, both tools will serve you well. But if you're thinking long-term, building a brand, growing a list, and optimizing performance, their differences start to matter more.
1. Publishing Experience
Substack
Substack provides a clean, distraction-free writing environment. You open a blank canvas, write your piece, add tags, and hit publish. No clutter, no complicated options. It's built for people who want to write consistently without worrying about tech or setup.
Substack automatically creates a web version of every post and emails it to your subscribers. You can also enable comments and community discussions.
Best for: Writers who want to publish with ease and focus on storytelling.
Beehiiv
Beehiiv also offers a smooth writing experience, but with more flexibility. You can:
- Create different types of posts (newsletter, web-only, hidden, etc.)
- Use built-in SEO options
- Add multiple sections per newsletter (great for curators or media-style newsletters)
It’s still beginner-friendly but feels like a step up for those who want to structure their content in a modular way.
Best for: Creators who want creative control over layout and strategy.
2. Custom Domain & Branding
Substack
Until recently, Substack lacked custom domain support, but that’s changed. You can now use your own domain (e.g., yourname.com), which helps with brand consistency and SEO.
However, customization beyond the basics is still limited. The layout, fonts, and structure remain largely uniform across Substack sites.
Beehiiv
Custom domains are a core feature in Beehiiv, even on their free plan. You can also customize your homepage, tweak the design, add newsletter sections, and use your own branding throughout the platform.
If building a branded media presence matters to you, Beehiiv offers more flexibility.
3. Monetization Options
Substack
Substack makes it easy to start charging for your newsletter. With just a few clicks, you can:
- Offer free or paid subscriptions
- Set monthly/yearly pricing
- Create subscriber-only posts
It also supports:
- Referral programs to reward subscribers who bring in new readers
- Integration with Apple Podcasts and video for multi-format creators
Substack takes 10% of your paid revenue plus Stripe fees.
Beehiiv
Beehiiv gives creators multiple monetization avenues:
- Paid subscriptions (with full control over pricing tiers)
- Lead capture & growth forms
- Ad monetization via Beehiiv’s Ad Network
- Referral programs with advanced reward systems
- Custom popups and gated content
- You can now also sell digital products like ebooks, templates and coaching.
Unlike Substack, Beehiiv doesn’t take a cut of your revenue, it's just your Stripe processing fees and your monthly plan.
4. Subscriber Management & Growth Tools
Substack
Substack includes basic audience analytics and growth tools. You can see:
- Total subscribers
- Open rates
- Recent growth
Substack’s network effect also helps creators grow organically. It features newsletters on the homepage, allows cross-promotion between creators, and lets readers discover new content via recommendations.
That said, it lacks deep segmentation and automation.
Beehiiv
Beehiiv was built with growth in mind. It includes:
- Audience segmentation (tag users based on behavior, source, or actions)
- Advanced analytics (CTR, conversion funnels, attribution)
- Custom referral program setup
- Built-in landing pages and embed forms
- Email automation and drip campaigns (for paid tiers)
These tools are ideal if you’re serious about understanding where your readers come from, and how to turn them into customers or loyal fans.
5. Pricing
Substack
Substack is free to use until you start charging. Once you enable paid subscriptions, they take 10% of your earnings (plus Stripe fees).
Substack is great for beginners or those who don’t want upfront costs.
Beehiiv
Beehiiv offers a free plan (up to 2,500 subscribers) and paid plans starting at $49/month.
- No revenue share
- Full control over monetization
- More features unlocked as you scale
Beehiiv is great for long-term newsletter businesses or those expecting to grow fast.
6. Community & Ecosystem
Substack
Substack has a built-in reader network. This allows creators to be discovered within the platform like a social feed for newsletters. Readers can comment, share, and follow multiple writers.
It also supports podcast and video publishing, letting creators build a multimedia presence.
Beehiiv
Beehiiv doesn’t have a discovery feed (yet), but it integrates well with external tools. It also supports:
- Web push notifications
- Google Analytics & Meta Pixel
- Zapier integrations
- Easy embed tools for websites
It gives you more control, but discovery will depend on your efforts via SEO, social, or ads.
Final Thoughts: Which One Is Right for You?
Choose Substack if:
- You want to write and publish quickly with minimal setup
- You like the idea of being discovered through a creator ecosystem
- You prefer a revenue share model over upfront payment
- You’re new to newsletters and want to get started with no financial risk
Choose Beehiiv if:
- You want to build a scalable newsletter business
- You care about segmentation, analytics, and growth tools
- You prefer to own your revenue (no platform fee)
- You plan to monetize through multiple channels (ads, subscriptions, sponsorships)
Looking to give Beehiiv a try?
👉 Sign up for free and start growing your newsletter today.
Comments ()